Member-only story
What Makes Peanut Butter so Addictive?
It’s the perfect combo of foods we crave
I’ve moved from being an emotional, compulsive eater into more healthy eating habits. In the past six months, I’ve lost 11 kilos (24 pounds) and I’ve kept the weight off. I’m a healthy BMI of 23.
And then, there’s peanut butter…
Two Spoonfuls is Never Enough
I wonder whether every healthy eater has their kryptonite — the food that pulls them back into overeating. For me, it’s peanut butter. I can’t just stop at one spoonful. Or even two.
There are some evenings where I’ll end up eating half a jar, undoing my exercise and healthy eating plan for the week. It’s so calorific that there are limited ways to recover from such a massive blip, other than returning to my healthy eating and avoiding the other half of the jar.

To get my mouth watering, I only have to think about how good peanut butter is:
- On a stack of pancakes, with maple syrup
- Spooned into my morning oats, with fresh Greek yogurt
- Baked into brownies